4th Grade · 5th Grade

Because of Mr. Terupt, Rob Buyea

My fifth grader recently read Because of Mr. Terupt for his nightly independent reading and raved about it. I decided to read it myself and review it.  He was right – it’s terrific!

The fifth graders in Mr. Terupt’s class thought they had it made when they got him as their teacher – after all, he was a rookie. But they didn’t know this would be the school year that would change their lives.

This book is written from the first-person perspectives of seven students as they recount the events of their extraordinary school year.

Their journal-like entries illustrate how Mr. Terupt gives them space to navigate challenges on their own, while teaching the principles of being positive, looking at things differently, always trying and, most importantly, forgiving.

When an accident involving their teacher leaves the students feeling helpless, blameful and shaken, they realize how much they need one another despite their differences, and they find themselves believing everything happens for a reason.

Buyea smoothly weaves the kids’ individual stories together in a way that keeps the plot moving forward. At the same time, he reveals details about each student that remind the reader that it’s easy to make assumptions about peers when you don’t really know them, but everyone has a story to tell.

Buyea wrote additional books, Mr. Terupt Falls Again and Saving Mr. Terupt, though we have not yet read them.  I anticipate they will be well worth reading.

1st Grade · 2nd Grade · 3rd Grade · 4th Grade · 5th Grade

Dear Boy, Written by Paris Rosenthal and Jason Rosenthal, Illustrated by Holly Hatam

My parents recently gifted this beautifully written and illustrated book to my boys, and it was such a touching and important read-aloud that I wanted to feature it as soon as possible.

Dear Boy uses simple, kid-friendly language in the form of a letter, teaching kids lessons they can carry with them for a lifetime. As you read the book with your boys, you are telling them it’s ok to feel cloudy and “let the rain fall,” that they should always believe in themselves, and “yes means yes” but “anything else means no.”

The book is a companion to the bestseller Dear Girl, which in the same style tells girls they are smart, that they should seek out people who are both like and unlike them, and “if (their) instinct is telling (them) to say no, say no.”

The story behind the books is touching as well. Dear Girl was written by the late children’s author Amy Krouse Rosenthal and her daughter, Paris Rosenthal. Amy passed away from ovarian cancer in March 2017, shortly after famously publishing her essay, “You May Want To Marry My Husband,” in the New York Times.  Amy’s husband, Jason, and their daughter, Paris, later teamed up to write the recently released Dear Boy.

The books are sweet reads with kids of any age. Both my fifth grader and first grader enjoyed them – and when I borrowed Dear Girl from the library to write this review, I read that to them as well. These books have such important lifelong messages that I may start including them with graduation gifts.

5th Grade

Out Of My Mind, Sharon M. Draper

“I like this book because it shows how people like Melody are really feeling.” This was my fifth grader’s observation when we were reading this book aloud and it’s the perfect testimonial for this New York Times bestseller. 

Melody is 11 years old and narrates her personal story about what it’s like to have cerebral palsy. She is extremely smart, but because she’s unable to speak she is schooled much below her grade level.  Melody feels very trapped and sometimes her frustrations lead to what she calls her “tornado explosions.” Her story takes a turn when her college-age aide, Catherine, helps her discover a life-changing device that gives her a voice. Equipped with this technology, she stuns her teachers and peers as she expresses her wealth of bottled-up knowledge and vies for a coveted spot on the school’s quiz competition team. 

Melody’s determination to overcome her obstacles is inspiring, and the first-person perspective is very eye opening.  Parents may find the book sparks some good family discussions about empathy.

4th Grade · 5th Grade

The Land of Stories: The Wishing Spell, Chris Colfer

Alex and Conner Bailey are typical modern-day sixth graders. They are twins, but while Alex is a bookworm, Conner is more the type to daydream in class. They have grown up listening to their world-traveler grandmother tell them amazing stories full of adventure in far-off places, and they relish the times when she would read fairy tales to them from her treasured Land of Stories book.

The first book in The Land of Stories series, The Wishing Spell, sets the stage when the twins’ grandmother gives them her Land of Stories book for their 12thbirthday. They are in for the adventure of their lives – they just don’t know it yet.

Author Chris Colfer, of “Glee” fame, takes the reader on a fascinating journey behind the scenes with a wide variety of fairy tale characters. He cleverly intertwines the lives of the Bailey twins with famed personalities like Goldilocks, Jack and the Beanstalk and Snow White – to name a few.  As we travel with the twins we discover what happened in “happily ever after,” look inside magic mirrors, and get the backstory on why Snow White’s stepmother was so evil.

Whether your kids are very familiar – or vaguely familiar – with fairy tales, this series is a great one to read together. We have now read the entire collection, and the books consistently held our interest and left us eager to read the next.  I can genuinely say I found the premise so intriguing that I would have loved reading this series independently as an adult.  

2nd Grade · 3rd Grade · 4th Grade · 5th Grade

The One and Only Ivan, Katherine Applegate

Ivan is a tenderhearted silverback gorilla that was born in Africa and captured by humans when he was young. We meet Ivan after he’s been living on display for years at the Exit 8 Big Top Mall and Video Arcade.

Ivan passes time as an artist, a talent he learned from the mall custodian’s daughter, Julia. He keeps company with several other animals in captivity, including a former circus elephant named Stella, now aging and tired. When Stella’s health begins to fail, Ivan promises to do everything in his power to secure a better life for a new arrival, a young orphaned elephant named Ruby. 

Ivan’s resourcefulness and commitment to follow through on his promise create a hopeful, warm read. His personality is endearing and one can’t help but feel empathy for Ivan, his friends and their circumstances.

I read this Newberry Medal winner aloud to my older son when he was in second grade. I also have seen older students enjoy reading it independently and in school book clubs.

5th Grade

Where the Red Fern Grows, Wilson Rawls

I had the most amazing pair of fifth grade teachers – the kind that truly influence life choices, and the kind you want to write a letter to 30 years later and tell them so. One of those teachers read this treasure aloud to our fifth grade class, and ever since it’s felt like a rite of passage to have my boys experience it when wrapping up elementary school and embarking on the middle school years.  This year I pulled it off the shelf to read with my fifth grade son and this classic book did not disappoint. 

The story takes place in the Ozark Mountains during the Great Depression. Our narrator is an adult Billy Colman, who recalls a particularly poignant time in his youth.

We join young Billy’s story when he’s ten years old and desperate to own a pair of coon hounds for hunting. He finds a sportsman’s magazine advertising his coveted dogs for twenty-five dollars each and works for two years to save the money. 

Billy and his hounds, Little Ann and Old Dan, become inseparable and gain notoriety locally as the best hunting team around.  They brave the challenges of the wilderness, encounter spiteful bullies, and see their unbreakable bond put to the ultimate test when they come face to face with a ruthless mountain lion.   

While this book could definitely be read independently, I can’t imagine experiencing it any other way than as a read aloud. Get your tissues ready.

5th Grade

The War That Saved My Life, Kimberly Brubaker Bradley

Set during World War II, this is the story of 10-year-old Ada, her younger brother, Jamie, and circumstances of war that proved lifesaving for both. Ada, who tells her story in a first-person perspective, was born with a clubfoot and suffered years of shame and neglect by her mother. She was frequently locked up in a small cabinet and was prohibited from going to school – or out in public at all. When the threat of bombings becomes imminent in London, local children are transported to the countryside for safety.  While her brother would likely go, Ada’s mom says she’s not worthy of leaving. Alongside her brother, Ada courageously and painfully escapes their dark and dirty apartment. The siblings find themselves living with Susan Smith, a single woman who coldly insists she knows nothing about taking care of children. As the book unfolds, we see the relationships grow between Ada, Jamie, Susan and other wonderful characters. And as Ada learns to love and trust Susan, she also begins to love herself.  

We enjoyed the book so much we also read The War I Finally Won, which picks up when Ada is 11.  In this equally touching sequel, a young Jewish girl from Germany moves into the house where Ada, Jamie and Susan are now living with a family we meet in the first book.   

I think it’s worth noting that although the main characters are female, my 10-year-old son was able to relate to the characters being his age.  I love bringing books into the mix that have strong female leads.  

4th Grade

Superstar, Mandy Davis

My older son gravitates toward books with characters facing intellectual or physical challenges.  Not surprisingly, he loved Wonder and its companion book Auggie and Me. So when I saw Superstar on display at our local library when he was in fourth grade, I knew this was one we had to read. 

Ten-year-old Lester Musselbaum narrates this heartwarming story from a first person perspective. Soon after we meet Lester, his mom delicately tells him that for the first time ever he will be enrolling in public school. Now in 5th grade, he has always been home-schooled by his mom, who now will be working at the local library during the day to make ends meet. Lester’s father was an astronaut and died on a mission years ago.

Lester loves science, space and predictability. He finds his unpredictable days at school to be harder than he anticipated and science lessons less enlightening than he hoped. He has to contend with bullies, but also makes a fashion-forward friend named Abby who remains present throughout the book. We loved rooting for Lester as he encountered new challenges, scientifically dissected the game of kickball, and indulged his scientific passions by entering the school science fair.

You’ll love reading this book with your kids or suggesting it as an independent read. The text can generate conversations about inclusion, acceptance and the mutual happiness that can come from unexpected friendships.

2nd Grade

The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane, Kate DiCamillo

We read this delightful novel aloud when my oldest was in second grade, and I can’t wait to read it with my little.  Edward Tulane is a sophisticated china rabbit with a tail and ears made of real rabbit fur. He wears fancy suits and has a gold pocket watch, which his adoring owner, 10-year-old Abilene, winds each day. When Abilene’s family embarks on a voyage to England on the Queen Mary, naturally Abilene takes Edward along. But when a scuffle with two young brothers ends with Edward going overboard, the endearing Edward begins an unexpected journey filled with new faces, new places and love lost and found.

1st Grade

The New Small Person, Lauren Child

Though most of my recommendations will be chapter books, I simply could not go without mentioning this treasure. This picture book follows Elmore Green’s transition from only child to big brother – and he experiences what it’s like to suddenly have to share the attention, a bedroom and his jellybeans. I had trouble making it through the book the first time without tearing up, as we see the relationship between the brothers grow and Elmore sees what it’s like to have a small person around who looks up to him and loves him so unconditionally. Perhaps I have a soft spot in my heart for this book because I have my own two boys – four years apart in age – and needless to say, we can relate. I’ve borrowed this book from our local library several times, and read it with both of my boys. I’ve also used it as a read-aloud book in their classrooms – hoping the sweet story makes a positive impression on another big brother or sister.